Paul's Place Reviews
Reviews from Citysearch
Overall Rating
- They have great burgers!
Read More On Citysearch by kalabings at Citysearch 1/5/2011 - Order a root beer and a burger.
Read More On Citysearch Citysearch User 3/15/2010 - Great if you're looking for a meal!This place looks kind of like one of those rowdy sports bars, but once you go inside, you feel better.
I got a cheeseburger and fries - both were so plentiful, I didn't finish either. I definitely got my money's worth. It costed me a bit less than ten bucks. Around eight.
The burger meat wasn't too seasoned, but that is how I like it. It was extremely juicy. It was so tender, you wouldn't need...
Read More On Citysearch Pink3rbellx 2/12/2010 - Fat Juicy BurgerThey don't mess around here. Burgers here are super big and juicy. If you are on diet, this is not the joint for you. If you are looking for a high maintenance burger, this aint the right spot for you either.
Be prepared to roll up your sleeves and chow down the messy burger at hand. You are certainly going to be full and happy after eating.
Read More On Citysearch Athena Chang 1/18/2010 - Best Burger i have ever hadI went to this place bc of the reviews that i read, The shop it self its not fancy and very laid back. The burger is huge and very delicious , I give them five starts.
Read More On Citysearch mangmang 10/23/2009 - Burger NirvanaA juicy burger cooked to perfection .. Need to use a knife and fork . Fresh ground beef which melts in your mouth
A small joint so timing is everything here
A friendly staff and intresting patrons that frequent the place
Read More On Citysearch jvig 5/11/2009 - Da Biggest Burgers in NYC.When I went there, as soon as I walked in, immediately smelled burgers a'cookin. Its the BEST diner/restaurant crossover in NYC. And thats no lie.
Read More On Citysearch bayside12 4/15/2009 - HUGE BurgersThis place makes some of the best burgers I've ever had. Whether you order rare or well done, the burgers are juicy and tasty. the Philly Cheesesteaks are really good too.
Read More On Citysearch amarti82 3/29/2009 - I Tell People This Place is Terrible......so they keep going to the Shake Shack. Hands down the best burger in New York. My biggest fear everytime I walk in is that the secret will finally be out and I'll find the tiny place packed to the gills and I'll have to wait for a table (hasn't happened yet in 7 years of going there). Burgers: juicy, seasoned to perfection and delicious. Toppings plentiful. Worried that your turkey burger will...
Read More On Citysearch cinematika 2/11/2009 - AWESOME BURGERS!Been to Paul's many times. Definitely one of the best burgers in the city. Delicious, fresh.......AWESOME!
Read More On Citysearch luvburgers 1/20/2009 - Here's what happens:1. You order the burger over the phone.
2. The burger arrives, lugged by a nice deliveryman.
3. You notice how the bun is frustratingly soggy.
4. You bite, then, into the burger.
5. The burger soothes all of your worries.
6. The burger turns on the TV.
7. You watch basketball.
Read More On Citysearch Citysearch User 1/8/2009 - overrated
I went to Paul?s Place a couple weeks ago after hearing/reading many good reviews and was hugely disappointed. The burger bun got too moist and ?what?s worse- gooey in a matter of minutes. The ground beef was bland because it had no salt on it. The paper-thin slice of Swiss was bland as well (domestic, most likely). The pickles were so old they were way too soft and had a weird smell and slightl...
Read More On Citysearch green01 1/2/2009 - Now This is a Good BurgerI have had my share of bad burgers but this is NOT the case with Paul's. I usually stop here whenever my kids visit me from out of state and want a cheeseburger. I have to admit I wouldn't dine inside only because it is a little cramp to dine in but that is the only negative thing I can say about the place. Put a tip in the tip jar and hear them honk the horn. My girlfriend and I usually order to...
Read More On Citysearch akatrk 12/27/2008 - The best burgers anywhere!!!I love burgers. I've eaten burgers at every self-professed "best burgers" joint. I can honestly say that without a doubt, Paul's burger was the best I've ever had. The only other place that comes close is Lou's Lunch in New Haven. I got an English burger - just a plain old burger with cheese on an English muffin. It didn't need a thing. The taste of the meat was amazing. I'm surprised they didn't...
Read More On Citysearch Lizziediz 5/20/2008 - Best Burger Ever ^_^ <3<3<3I went to Paul's Burger Joint last Saturday with my boyfriend, after Self's Workout in the Park. Lol. But we were deciding on Dallas BBQ across the street or Paul's but we were tired of eating chicken at home. Best decision ever made. I had a Cheese Burger Deluxe sub. Sweet Potato fries and Boyfriend had Soul Burger Deluxe. OMG that first ever lovin' bite just melted in my mouth. It was juicy, no...
Read More On Citysearch ljones86 5/16/2008 - Huge burgers. I haven't tried anything else,...
Read More On Citysearch by parkhyein at Menuism 4/19/2008 - def. the best in NY
Read More On Citysearch by zoobuffalo at Menuism 1/14/2008 - Love at First BiteI've had the great fortune of ordering the East Sider Deluxe (Gigantic burger with heaps of bacon, cheese, mushrooms, sauteed onions, tomato, raw onions, and lettuce.. with mounds of crispy fries on the side) last night and loved it from the first bite to the last greasy crumb. This is coming from a guy who loves red meat and has tasted many different burgers from numerous places around the city...
Read More On Citysearch xikenx 12/18/2007 - Dee-LishThere's really no reason to come here if you're not having a burger. Cheap, low maintenance, quick and easy.
No matter how many fancy restaurants open up, just admit it, at heart, we're all burger loving slobs.
Read More On Citysearch cowcowfcpc 9/6/2007 - The best burger I've eaten so far---in NYC; many varietie...
Read More On Citysearch by kentbwong at Menuism 8/27/2007 - Before a night of heavy drinking or the following afternoon...I have a Paul's Burger. It can't be beat. If red meat kills, allow me to help you pick out my casket. As long as Paul's is around, I'm not going strict veg anytime too soon. There's a (one single) guy behind the counter when I go there "the morning after." I'm not sure if it's Paul but whoever this guy is, whoa! If you're reading this, you should work nights because the guys on the grill in the e...
Read More On Citysearch yourwarmembrace 8/3/2007 - great burgers!My first bite into this bacon cheddar cheese burgers was a burst of beefy juice flavor, I ordered medium rare (pink center) but it came to be a medium (no pink) which i thought wasn't cool but it was still awesome regardless. This place would have easily been a 5 star by me if i didn't order the onion rings which were $3.20 dollars for a hefty plate of frozen pathmark onion rings which were just ...
Read More On Citysearch pest786 7/23/2007 - AWESOME!Paul's got so many variety of burgers. I am never disappointed. Whether it's the Bacon Cheeseburger or Burger with Feta...they are all good! I like the atmosphere...and the area of course. Order the deluxe---the fries and shakes are good too!
Read More On Citysearch mxtarantino 6/3/2007 - BEST BURGER EVER!i LOVE this place. my mouth is watering just thinking about their burgers. The patties are big, the fries are delicious and the staff is no BS. If you are ever in the east village, you HAVE to drop by here for a burger. I've brought many friends here and no one has ever been disappointed.
Read More On Citysearch nychead 11/18/2006 - Best Burgers in NYC!Paul's has got to be the best burgers in NYC! Visited last sunday for lunch. The burgers are huge and fresh and juicy as can be! I recommend the sweet potato fries! Plus our waitress was a breath of fresh air...SO nice and prompt and seemed to actually like her job...something you rarely find! The place is small, but that's what makes it what it is.
Read More On Citysearch nashvegasfoodie 9/7/2006 - I've never finished a burger here...without first mentally preparing myself. i go by myself (it's always hard to find a nice place to eat alone) order a St. Mark's burger, and watch whatever sporting event they have one TV.
I've never been bothered yet, and even though it's a cheap ($10 including tip for a deluxe burger, fries, and a freely refilled coke) place I like it the best.
PROS: eat here alone
CONS: far from the tra...
Read More On Citysearch Citysearch User 8/14/2006 - best burger anywhere, great customer service!just go...killer burgers, awesome atmosphere!!! the place is small...so what, this is nyc baby, not frikin' texas! the buns are smaller than the burger...so what i'd rather pay to have more meat than bread, which cost pennies to make and it's just a filler anyway! no fillers needed for these half-pound burger beauties! they really go down smooth, no heavy feeling like with other burgers. bottom...
Read More On Citysearch peajam45 7/18/2006 - AMAZING burgers!So if you're ever craving half a pound of thick, juicy beef, Paul's is your place. I agree with previous comments that the buns are perhaps a little small, but you can always whip out a knife and fork and find a way to make it work... or just deal and get a little messy. The burgers don't make you feel like you're going to die later either, which I found to be a plus (no guarantees if that hold...
Read More On Citysearch defyinggravity05 7/14/2006 - Is there really anywhere else in NYC?All about the burger! Do not forget the really thick chocolate milkshake(they have a name for the really thick one)(best chocolate milkshake in NYC, anyone?), a beer ot two at less than $4.00 each in NYC, and amazing pickles. Paul's brought my wife around to eating red meat, and for that I THANK YOU!!!!
Read More On Citysearch joekross 7/12/2006 - Killer!Hands down best burger in the East Village! Rare with Cheddar and Bacon is the move. Good guys at the counter too.
Read More On Citysearch chowfiend 7/8/2006 - Gotta be the bestPaul's keeps it "real" with what must be the best burger in the city, if not on the east coast. I keep going back despite the abundance of other eateries in the East Village. It just keeps getting better & better. Long live Paul & his place!
Read More On Citysearch Dcatlin 4/7/2006 - No Better Burgers Anywhere!Paul's Place serves the juciest burgers with delicious steak fries. Large variety of burgers. Bowls of pickle slices at tables. Paul, the owner, is always there for many visits & he /staff are friendly. You will not be disappointed.
Read More On Citysearch nytimes00 3/18/2006 - This is where to get your burgerNo one leaves hungry at Paul's.
NO ONE.
Big juicy burgers, generous portions, all at good prices.
It can get pretty busy and the service is sometimes poor but the pros outweigh the cons.
For a burger joint you can't go wrong.
Read More On Citysearch ironchef666 12/8/2005 - These Burgers Are Grrrrrreat!!!!If you like to eat and you like a good burger you need to eat at paul's. Best burger on the eastern seaboard bar none.
Read More On Citysearch fsc96 10/5/2005 - the best burgers
Read More On Citysearch by Laura B. at Judy's Book 7/26/2005 - great big beefy burgersSome of the best and biggest burgers in the city! Paul's really is an experience. One burger is more than enough. You might even go home with leftovers. These thick, juicy burgers are cooked on a grill behind the couter - and there is a bowls of amazing pickles on every table. The milkshakes are nice and thick also. Try it - but only go if you're HUNGRY.
Read More On Citysearch Citysearch User 7/14/2005 - Best Burgers For Less
Read More On Citysearch by Janine G. at Judy's Book 4/22/2005 - solid burgersThis place serves one of the better burgers I've ever had. The burgers are bigger than at other places and the beef was juicy. It's kind of strange that they charge extra for lettuce and tomatoes, but it still turns out being around 5$ a burger; not a bad deal at all considering the quality of the burger.
Read More On Citysearch ts2212 4/2/2005 - best burgers in the worldI love New York it is the greatest city and the atomosphere is beautiful. I visit New York often and everytime my boyfriend and friends always go to paul's. I can never leave without one of those many different versions of burgers. i highly recommend it. Its cozy and i lke the decor. remeinds me of a 50's restaurant.
Read More On Citysearch spacelyx 3/16/2005 - SOLIDThis place has the best burgers ever! The atmosphere is cool. Even though the place is kind of small, it doesn't matter. There are so many things to look at and all, you really don't care. LOVE IT!!!!!
Read More On Citysearch helly_ny 3/16/2005 - The BestThe best burger, hands down. I go once a week.
Read More On Citysearch sk5031 2/11/2005 - Don't miss Paul'sPaul's is really worth a visit. A high-quality old New York hamburger joint. The service was fine - really sweet, pleasant guys despite huge crowding. Burger also fine. I don't think the quality of the burger quite measures up to J.G. Melon or that place in the West Village that's always rated 'best burger,' and I do think Paul is scrimping on the bun quality and on the American cheese qualit...
Read More On Citysearch nomdepluum 7/24/2004 - PROTEIN doseGym friends from out of town requested lean protein in the form of beef- couldnt wait to take them to Paul's. Sure, its not grilled chicken breast, but these burgers are top notch without the Fast Food poisons. Seemed like other weightlifters had the same idea- we were not the only ones in there. We preferred to gaze at our burgers while avoiding having to look at the wait staff, but no complain...
Read More On Citysearch superherox 7/8/2004 - JUST LIKE HOME PAUL'S PLACE HAS SUCH A GREAT ATMOSPHERE, IT FEELS LIKE YOUR AT HOME. FROM THE WARM WELCOME TILL YOUR FINAL DEPARTURE. THE FOOD IS FABULOUS AND THE PEOPLE ARE GREAT. THE INTERIOR IS VERY INTERESTING WITH PAUL'S COLLECTION OF COLLECTABLES TOO HIS HD TV'S.
Read More On Citysearch cableguy9957 6/11/2004 - Yummy!!!BIG home made burgers for practially the same price as Mickey D's. Lots of choices to add on. Opt for a kaiser roll ($ .25 extra). The burger is just too big for a standard bun. Also, we always pig out on the pickles they have sitting on all their tables. One small complaint, onion rings are pre fab frozen, so they were a small let down otherwise a great place for a quick bite.
Read More On Citysearch guidomom 5/13/2004 - great burgerforget decor, if you are looking for the best hamburger from a "hamburger joint" in nyc this place is hands down the best. grilled onions sauted mushroom and cheese as good as it gets.
Read More On Citysearch ajm351 5/8/2004 - The food is good but the service suckedI went to try Paul's palace last weekend cuz I heard a lot of good things about it. The food was good, but the service sucked soooooo badly. I know the place was busy and all I didn't wanna hear the waiter cursing before he took our order.
Read More On Citysearch allovertheworld 3/16/2004 - Worth the 3,000 mile trip!Paul's is great... I was there opening week, and a frequent visitor for yeas until I moved to California. I return to NYC a few times a year, and always to Paul's for the BEST burgers anywhere!
Read More On Citysearch tomedic 8/23/2003 - best place to be antisocialPaul's is most definately the best burger on earth that i have encountered. I don't go there for the service, which is whatever. But damn! can they make a burger.
Read More On Citysearch evenstephen 7/27/2003 - Absolutely Superb BurgerI visit the U.S. quite often, and I am always looking for a great place to eat whenever I go. This time I was in the mood for Hamburgers. Since I was here for a week, I utilized CitySearch and tried all of the Editorial Nominees. Without a doubt, Paul's Palace was by far the best hamburger I have ever tasted. The service was very friendly, and the gizmos and toys added to the delightful colour o...
Read More On Citysearch geezer 7/15/2003 - Great Freaken Burgers!I've been eating at Pauls for the last 11 years and it is by far the best Burger in New York City! I've tried the other burgers at most of the top 10 spots on this list, and not one, (NOT ONE!) beats the Burgers at Pauls. These Burgers Freaken ROCK! Period! Now go and try one for yourself, and you better be hungry, cause Paul's ain't for dieters, light eaters, and vegetarians!
Read More On Citysearch exmarine 7/13/2003 - Best Burgers in NYCPaul's has the best burgers in NYC. Period. You get a huge juicy burger with some excellent steak fries for a very reasonable price. If you're looking for a great hamburger, look no further than Paul's.
Read More On Citysearch rossmassey 7/9/2003 - Great Burgers.I live a few blocks from Paul's, and I go there at least a few times a week. The burgers are big and juicy, and they give you a lot of steak fries with the deluxe. I'd say I've been there in an upwards of 100 times, and the food has tasted good every time. I don't usually dine in though, so I wouldn't know about the experience.
Read More On Citysearch gorch 1/29/2003 - burger heavengreat burgers, all the pickles you can eat and a good selection of beer, what else could a person want?
Read More On Citysearch ag6ob 1/11/2003 - burger bonanzaDon't be fooled by the "flame broiled burger scam" . Burgers are best fried on a flat grill surface where they stay moist and juicy, just as they do it at Paul's. Unlike other joints, there really is a Paul, he is a great guy who will lead you to burger nirvana. Go once and you will never eat burgers anywhere else!
Read More On Citysearch brienzaj 1/10/2003 - Wimpy would be proud!Paul's is by far the best burger joint in the city. I've since, taken my girlfriend there, friends and family and they all agree. Paul's is the best. The best part is that they will custom make any burger if it's not on the menu. And they know the difference between Medium, Rare and Well-done! Go there on an empty stomach. This stuff is what America is all about.
Read More On Citysearch ghostwheel4 12/4/2002 - GREAT BURGERS!!!Burgers are great, good choice of sides. Service is sometimes slow but worth the wait. Four to Five people can eat for the price of 2 in any other place.
And they have Philly Chessesteaks!!!!
Read More On Citysearch doxmaster 11/13/2002 - Good Burgers But Wack Service
The burgers are really good here. However, the buns are soggy and service sucks...especially for take-out...they never get it right!!!! Eat-in for a okay experience...
Read More On Citysearch Savedadogs 10/26/2002 - great foodGreat food in a friendly atmosphere. Huge burgers and meals are quick, good and inexpensive.
Read More On Citysearch JFBrock 10/25/2002 - Paul's is best...and their hamburger tartar is to die for. Large servings, yummy burger.
Read More On Citysearch janet_clarke 8/30/2002 - f milk, got meat?this place rocks. there are smaller sized tables so it is best for 1-4 people, really the best for 2 going to eat together. However there is stuff flying back and forth across the ceilings, great smells, and oh the anticipation of your burger. I am not sure how they do it, or why it is so different, but these burgers are unbelievable. cooked so well, but they stay "soft" somehow. just amaz...
Read More On Citysearch ccanderman 8/26/2002 - best burgersSimply the best bugers in town. Wide variety of burger styles - all are winners.
Read More On Citysearch russelllombardy 8/25/2002 - Beefybeef, grease, no-frills bun. What more could one need? Sweet potato fries are a nice addition.
Read More On Citysearch MattNYC 8/23/2002 - Makes Vegetarians Seem StupidThis is the best red meat on the face of the planet, I swear. I grew up in the midwest, and NEVER had a burger this good. If I lived near Pauls I would accept the fact I'm dying of a heart attack before 30.
Read More On Citysearch padawin 8/15/2002 - Sex on a bunI recently ate at Paul's burger palace and I must say the burgers were a good as sex! It was juicy, the buns were soft and squishy, the onions and tomotos were sliced thin...OOOO...OOOOOOO....OOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!! I've tried them all and this is best I've had.
Read More On Citysearch lainiecantrell 8/12/2002 - Best Bacon Burger, Baby! Without a doubt, the Absolute Best and Tastiest Burgers in New York! Go ahead and go to the other places on this list (I have), and you will still wind up coming back to Paul's. The Burgers are just too good to pass up, and it's a fun place to eat.
If you're hungry, and NOT on a diet, then there is no other place to eat a Great Tasting Burger than Paul's. My Favorite is the Very Juicy Bacon Bu...
Read More On Citysearch scoutx 8/8/2002 - The Very BestJuicy burgers bulging out of hearty buns...excellent fries and cold beer. Very reasonable prices. PLUS all those great, whimsical characters buzzing around the place that keep my 2-year-old daughter occupied throughout the meal. This place is paradise!
Read More On Citysearch nymart 8/8/2002 - GO THERE HUNGRY!I used to work across the street from Paul's in 1989 and that's how we discovered the place. We live in Jersey now, but whenever we have a chance, we would go and eat the burgers at Paul's. Very tasty, huge burgers, great atmosphere. NEO...
Read More On Citysearch proe 8/8/2002 - juicily deliciousPaul's Palace has tasty juicy burgers - they are the right size with the right size buns. The burgers are about the best in the city.
Read More On Citysearch moviepal 8/8/2002 - Here's the Beef!If you are looking for a damn good burger Paul's is the place. They have a wide variety of choices and all toppings are served in abundance. The decor reminds me of a roadside diner along Route 66. This place is for all types, from trendy NYU'ers to sports lovers - games are always on.
Read More On Citysearch Urbanite 8/6/2002 - I think I'm gonna have to go right now..Man, just reading the reviews about Paul's is making me hungry. I stop in there a couple times a month and gorge myself on the City's biggest and best burgers. Needless to say, I have to crawl home more often than not, but I guess that's the price you pay for eating one of those masterpieces from paul's...
Read More On Citysearch willisdrummond 8/6/2002 - oh my godtheir burgers are unreal, they taste like a burger you would dream about say on a desserted island and satisfy that burger urge for months
Read More On Citysearch fabulousfawn 8/5/2002 - good enough for tartarQuality of meat is good enough to eat as tartar. Burgers any way you like it. The best toppings with fries to match. Definitely the best burger there is!
Read More On Citysearch minuet99 7/27/2002 - Wow!Burgers is what they do. About 50 different ones,
plus you can create your own.
Be prepared, they are huge!
Read More On Citysearch feurtado2002 7/24/2002 - Best Burgers!It's hard to find burgers where you get what you ask for. Paul's is one of those few places where you get a medium-rare when you ask for medium rare.
Milkshakes are pretty darn good, too.
Waitstaff is awfully friendly.
Read More On Citysearch youngonbrdwy 6/8/2002
Reviews from MetroGuide.Community
Overall Rating
There are currently no active or available MetroGuide.Community reviews for this listing.
© 1996-2013, MetroGuide, Inc. | Privacy Policy | Terms and Conditions
MetroGuide, MetroGuide.Network and MetroGuide New York are service marks of MetroGuide.com, Inc.
To contact us at MetroGuide: Click Here.